Menu of Scoops & More Eatery in Oakdale, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Scoops & More Eatery, nestled on Steubenville Pike in Oakdale, PA, delivers a vibrant blend of classic American diner fare and standout ice cream treats. Though the name hints primarily at frozen delights, this eatery offers a surprisingly broad and satisfying menu that caters to both sweet cravings and savory appetites.

Their sundaes truly shine. The Turtle Sundae and Brownie Sundae are crowd favorites, with the latter impressing reviewers thanks to a generous warm brownie base topped with rich ice cream. This combo balances warmth and creaminess beautifully, making it an excellent indulgence. The Chocolate Peanut Sundae and Vanilla Ice Cream with Baklava Topping introduce creative, layered flavors that elevate the traditional sundae experience.

The savory offerings stand strong beside their desserts. The hot dogs and specialty pizzas—ranging from classic White Pizza to the bold Buffalo Chicken Pizza and a gluten-free Hawaiian Pizza—reflect both variety and quality at an approachable price point of about $10 per pie. Sandwiches, like the well-loved Turkey Bacon Club and the Ham, Egg & Cheese Club, stack flavor with fresh lettuce, tomato, and mayo, fulfilling hearty lunch needs. Customers like Ulyana K highlight the substantial size and savory balance of their fried fish sandwich with mushrooms, provolone, and ranch, noting it as a great value.

The sides deserve mention too. Fries, especially the Buffalo Chicken Fries, receive enthusiastic praise for being crispy outside and fluffy inside, paired expertly with Scoops & More's standout ranch dressing—creamy and rich, it elevates each bite whether served with fries or fish.

Soft serve enthusiasts find satisfaction in simple but excellent offerings: creamy chocolate and vanilla soft serves, along with refreshing lemon or raspberry dole whip. These treats are affordably priced, making them an irresistible stop for a quick, cool dessert. The milkshakes, particularly the peanut butter cup twist variety, offer a delightful texture with chunks of peanut butter pieces, though some customers yearn for a thicker, creamier consistency.

What sets Scoops & More Eatery apart is the balance between quality, portion size, and genuine hospitality. Despite occasional busy moments causing slight delays, the service remains courteous and efficient—one of the many reasons customers keep returning. The menu’s diversity—from ice cream to pizzas to sandwiches—makes it a versatile destination for families, casual diners, and ice cream lovers alike.

In essence, Scoops & More Eatery captures the essence of a classic American diner while adding a creative twist to both food and ice cream. It’s a place that satisfies comfort food cravings with an inviting atmosphere, compelling menu variety, and memorable flavors that resonate beyond the final bite.